I encountered a strange problem in MIDAS SET for concrete shear capacity of a column.

Solving a simple column example;

B=500mm

H=500mm

Cover=50mm so d = 450mm

Axial Factored Load is 700kN Compression

f’c = 45 MPa

Ag = 500×500 = 500 mm²

From ACI-318(05M) chapter 11, equation 11-4 we get;

**Vc = 0.17 (1 + Nu/14Ag) (f’c^0.5) b.d**

Where Nu/Ag term should be in N/mm²

Nu is –ve for TENSION and +ve for compression

So putting all these values in this equation we get;

**Vc = [ 0.17 ( 1 + 700*1000/14/500² ) (45^0.5) 500 x 450 ] / 1000 = 307.91 kN**

**and Phi Vc = 0.75×307.91 = 230.93 kN**

whereas in MIDAS software, it gives Phi Vc in both the directions equal to 612.0 kN. This value is more than 2 times the value we calculated from ACI equation.

Your calculation is wrong.Nu in ACI code is N.700kN=700000N.

Thanks for the comment and I have updated the calculations.

your calculation is wrong.Nu in ACI code is N not kN.so you must put number 700000N to calculate this Vu the result is 307.907kN

Thanks for the comment and I have updated the calculations.